Why Ontario can’t seem to ease its debt burden
Government debt has grown much faster than the economy in recent years.
The Ontario government’s determination to keep adding new debt suggests it simply isn’t serious about getting the crucial debt-to-GDP ratio down any time soon. That’s bad news for taxpayers.
The government has repeatedly stated the importance of bringing down the province’s debt-to-GDP (gross domestic product) ratio, which shot up during and after the 2008-09 recession. It wants to bring this metric (which economists use to measure the sustainability of a government’s debt burden) back to its pre-recession level of 26%.
An elevated debt burden means more taxpayer dollars go to interest payments and are unavailable for other important priorities. Unfortunately, Premier Kathleen Wynne’s government has made little progress towards this objective. After a period of rapid increase, the ratio peaked at 39.1% in 2014-15. Since then, it has inched down – but very slowly.
This year, Ontario’s debt-to-GDP ratio is expected to ease by 0.3 percentage points, to 37.5%. The government expects even less progress next year. At this rate, it will take decades to get back to pre-recession levels.
So the government has set an important goal, but is making almost no progress. Why?
Because the Ontario government continue to add new debt.
For a jurisdiction to shrink its debt-to-GDP ratio, it doesn’t need to actually stop adding debt. It needs only for the pace of new debt accumulation to be slower (in percentage terms) than the rate of nominal economic growth. If that happens, the debt-to-GDP ratio shrinks. If the opposite occurs, it goes up.
Ontario has gotten into so much trouble in recent years because its government debt grew so much faster than the economy. Between 2008 and 2016, nominal annual economic growth in Ontario averaged 3.2%. Meanwhile, nominal debt grew more than twice as fast – averaging 7.6% growth annually. This meant the debt-to-GDP ratio climbed significantly.
The government can only reverse this damage if GDP growth begins to significantly outpace the growth of debt.
With the government forecasting annual nominal GDP growth of more than 4% between 2017 and 2019, it’s possible to reduce the ratio substantially and reasonably quickly – but only if the government stops piling up debt or at least dramatically slows down the pace.
Unfortunately, the government’s fiscal plan calls for more debt in the years ahead, including an average of $11.8 billion annually in new debt between now and 2019-20. That’s almost the exact amount it added annually over the past three years.
This means the province’s nominal debt will grow at an average rate of 3.6% annually over the next three years. It’s slower than the forecasted pace of nominal GDP growth but just barely. So the provincial debt-to-GDP ratio will hover very close to its current level for years. And this minimal progress relies on upbeat economic projections, which are hardly set in stone.
If getting the debt-to-GDP ratio down were a priority, Ontario would follow Quebec, which hasn’t added to its very large nominal net debt load since 2014. With no new net debt, economic growth is shrinking Quebec’s debt-to-GDP ratio at a good clip – by 1.2 percentage points this year.
This contrast of real action in Quebec with empty rhetoric in Ontario is an important reason why Quebec’s credit rating was recently upgraded above Ontario’s. It’s also why, in a stunning historic reversal, Ontario’s per-person net provincial debt will exceed Quebec’s for the first time next year.
Simply put, if Ontario is serious about getting out of its debt hole, it must finally stop digging.
This article was written with Charles Lamman. Eisen and Lamman are analysts with the Fraser Institute and co-authors of Wishful Thinking: an analysis of Ontario’s timeline for shrinking its debt burden. Distributed by Troy Media © 2017.