Singh accuses Trudeau of disrespect for voters after PM leaves 3 ridings vacant

By Joan Bryden   

Industry Government Byelection Jagmeet Singh Liberals NDP Trudeau

A byelection has yet to be called for the riding the NDP leader hopes to win.

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh. PHOTO: Jagmeet Singh/Twitter

OTTAWA—Jagmeet Singh is accusing Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of playing games with his decision to call one byelection while leaving three other ridings vacant—including the one in which the NDP leader plans to run.

Singh, who intends to run for Parliament in Burnaby South, said Monday that Trudeau is showing no respect for some 300,000 voters who’ve been left without representation in the three ridings.

“All these people deserve to have their voices heard and this government is saying their voices don’t matter,” said Singh. “It certainly was an example of Justin Trudeau playing some petty political games because … in the past any time there’s byelections that could be called, government has called them all together.”

Singh has struggled to find his groove since winning the NDP leadership a year ago and the party’s fundraising and polling numbers have dropped accordingly. New Democrats hope he can turn that around by winning a seat in the Commons and some suspect Trudeau is delaying the byelection in Burnaby South to deprive Singh of greater visibility.


Related: NDP MP slams Trudeau for not calling byelection in Jagmeet Singh’s B.C. riding [Canadian Manufacturing]

But Liberal insiders scoff at that notion. Instead, they say their concern is that Singh will lose the byelection, prompting the NDP to dump him and choose a potentially more appealing leader before next fall’s general election.

The prime minister must call a byelection within six months of an MP’s leaving a seat. The actual election date can be much later.

The NDP leader faced his own questions about how well the constituents of Burnaby South were represented by former New Democrat MP Kennedy Stewart, who waited four months after launching his successful run for Vancouver mayor to give up his seat in the House of Commons.

Had Stewart resigned when he launched his mayoral bid on May 10, the six-month limit would be almost up and Trudeau would have no choice but to call a byelection.

Singh dodged repeated questions about why Stewart didn’t resign earlier and whether he thinks Burnaby South constituents were well served by the New Democrat MP while he was actively campaigning for another job for four months.

“The question is why is it the goverment has called one byelection but not the other three,” Singh said, adding that Stewart “continued to be vocal” on issues that matter in the riding.

On Sunday, Trudeau set Dec. 3 as the date for a byelection in the eastern Ontario riding of Leeds-Grenville-Thousand Islands and Rideau Lakes. That riding has been without an MP for almost six months, since the death of Conservative Gordon Brown on May 2.

In addition to Burnaby South, Trudeau did not call byelections in two other ridings: the Montreal riding of Outremont, left vacant by the Aug. 3 resignation of former NDP leader Tom Mulcair; and the Ontario riding of York-Simcoe, left vacant by the Sept. 30 resignation of Conservative MP Peter Van Loan.

“It has been mere weeks since those seats were vacated,” Trudeau told the House of Commons on Monday. “We will call those elections in due course, as is required under the Elections Act.”

New Democrat MP Peter Julian dismissed Trudeau’s “weak and insipid response” and suggested the real reason for “this petty act” is that “the prime minister is scared of the reaction of the voters.”

Trudeau retorted that voters in the three ridings aren’t getting the full four years of service from the MPs they elected, adding that “the sanctimony from the NDP on this is, as always, amusing.”

In Trudeau’s inner circle, debate has been raging for weeks over whether the Liberals should run a candidate against Singh or stand aside to give him a better shot at victory. The final decision is up to the prime minister but insiders now expect the Liberals will run a candidate because that’s what the party grassroots in British Columbia want.

Liberals believe they can pick up Outremont, which was a Liberal stronghold before Mulcair snagged it for the NDP in 2007, but they think an upset there will have more impact early in the new year, rather than just before Christmas.

Trudeau is likely to group Outremont together with the other vacant ridings for byelections early in the new year. That will include a fourth riding—British Columbia’s Nanaimo-Ladysmith, where New Democrat MP Sheila Malcolmson last week announced her intention to run for an open provincial seat.


Stories continue below

Print this page

Related Stories