High mercury levels form ‘bull’s eye’ around oil sands

Environment Canada study suggests developments are a source of airborne emissions.

June 5, 2014   by CANADIAN PRESS

FORT MCMURRAY, Alta. — An Environment Canada study has found elevated levels of mercury in northern Alberta with the bull’s-eye centred on oil sands developments.

“These results suggest that oil sands developments are a source of airborne (mercury) emissions to local landscapes and water bodies,” says the study, which has been reviewed and published in the journal Environmental Science and Technology.

Levels of the most dangerous form of the potent neurotoxin are about 13 times higher than normal in the most affected area, about 60 kilometres north of Fort McMurray and a little east of the community of Fort McKay.

Although levels quickly drop off from there, scientists found that almost 17,000 square kilometres have been affected by elevated mercury deposits that probably come from industrial emitters.


“Highest mercury concentrations were observed at 15 sites within the major oil sands development area,” the paper says.

The conclusions are based on springtime snowpack samples taken in 2011 and 2012 from up to 89 sites in the heart of the oil sands region and as far away as 200 kilometres.
Testing showed that as industrial activity increased, so did mercury levels.

“Deposition resembled a bull’s-eye on the landscape, with areas of maximum (mercury) located primarily between the Muskeg and Steepbank rivers,” the report says.

That pattern also held for methylmercury, the most dangerous form of the element, which is absorbed and accumulated by plants and animals.

The report acknowledges mercury levels were never measured before the industry’s expansion, so it’s hard to nail down a normal level. Mercury occurs naturally in the environment.

The authors consider mercury levels 200 kilometres north of the major developments to be normal. For methylmercury, that was about 1.5 billionths of a gram per square metre.
Methylmercury levels in the centre of the bull’s-eye were about 19 billionths of a gram.
That chemical was also strongly linked with other metals and contaminants known to come from oil sands facilities.

“The positive significant relationships observed between (mercury) and other contaminants known to be emitted from oil sands-related processes suggest that mercury is also released directly to the atmosphere from industrial processes,” says the study, which was first discussed in preliminary form last December at a scientific conference.

The researchers caution mercury levels drop off quickly. About 80% of the study area showed fewer accumulations than the worst hit region. As well, those levels remain well under federal guidelines for mercury concentrations.

They conclude more study is needed to understand how the toxin accumulates in plants and animals.

The research, conducted under the joint Alberta-Ottawa oil sands monitoring program, chimes with other research that links environmental toxins with industrial emissions. Other papers have linked both heavy metals and hydrocarbons in spring snowpacks to the oil sands.

The author of the study was not available for comment. Environment Canada spokesman Mark Johnson said to date, the results of environmental monitoring in the oil sands region show that low levels of oil sands development-related substances are present in both air and water.

Mercury levels found in the oil sands region snowpack near the development are above the background levels but below guidelines, with levels decreasing as one gets farther from development, he said.

Johnson also said mercury levels are low compared with many industrial developments, and are only slightly higher than those found in relatively undeveloped areas such as northwestern Ontario.

“Considering methylmercury is a neurotoxin that bioaccumulates in the food web, it is important to continue tracking mercury levels in the oil sands development area to ensure they remain below acceptable levels,” Johnson said in an email to The Canadian Press.

Last month, Alberta Health issued a warning about eating eggs from some water birds downstream from the oil sands.

An Environment Canada study found that levels of mercury have gone up significantly in the eggs in the last three decades, with some increases of up to 139 per cent. In at least one species, mercury levels were high enough to start harming the birds.

© 2014 The Canadian Press

Print this page

Related Stories