2010 BP rig explosion: manslaughter charges dropped
Misdemeanours remain for two lower-level supervisors
Oil & Gas
oil and gas
NEW ORLEANS — After a BP rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico, killing 11 workers and causing the nation’s worst offshore oil disaster, the Justice Department launched a sweeping and costly criminal investigation. For roughly two years, a task force of FBI agents and prosecutors occupied an entire floor of a high-rise building across from the federal courthouse in New Orleans.
The government did secure a landmark criminal settlement and record civil penalties against the energy giant, which BP said would ultimately cost the corporation $53.8 billion. But in terms of individual criminal responsibility, only four mostly lower-ranking employees faced charges, and even those cases unravelled before skeptical jurors and judges.
The Justice Department’s latest setback was self-inflicted: At the request of prosecutors, a judge agreed to dismiss manslaughter charges against two supervisors who were working on the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig when it exploded in April 2010.
The decision makes it increasingly likely that nobody will serve a day in prison for the disaster.
“This is a devastating loss for the government and is a reflection that, despite all good intentions the government may have, sometimes tragedies are just tragedies,” said Michael Magner, a former federal prosecutor in New Orleans who represented the only BP executive who was charged, winning his acquittal this year on a count of making false statements to investigators.
Relatives of the victims were less charitable.
“As a result of this court proceeding today, no man will ever spend a moment behind bars for killing 11 men for reasons based entirely on greed,” said Keith Jones, whose son Gordon Jones died in the rig explosion. He attended the Dec. 2 hearing with his other children, and expressed disappointment that prosecutors dropped the most serious charges.
Donald Vidrine, one of the two rig supervisors indicted on manslaughter charges, pleaded guilty to a misdemeanour charge of violating the Clean Water Act. A lawyer for the other rig supervisor, Robert Kaluza, said his client will fight the same remaining charge at a trial scheduled to start in February.
“From Bob’s standpoint, he’s charged with a crime he didn’t commit, and he’s going to go to trial to clear his name,” said Kaluza’s attorney, Shaun Clarke.
The cases against two other BP employees already have been resolved.
Former BP executive David Rainey was acquitted in June of manipulating calculations to match a far-too-low estimate of the amount of oil spewing into the Gulf. A judge dismissed a related charge, that Rainey obstructed a congressional investigation of the spill.
Former BP engineer Kurt Mix was convicted of obstruction of justice in 2013 for deleting a string of text messages, but allegations of juror misconduct led a judge to order a new trial, and Mix ultimately cut a deal with prosecutors, who agreed to drop the obstruction charge punishable by up to 20 years in prison. Mix pleaded guilty last month to a lesser charge and was sentenced to six months of probation.
Anthony Badalamenti, a former manager for Halliburton Energy Services Inc., BP’s cement contractor on the rig, was sentenced to one year of probation after pleading guilty to a misdemeanour _ destroying evidence in the aftermath of the spill.
The Deepwater Horizon rig, which London-based BP PLC leased from Swiss-based Transocean Ltd., was about 48 miles from the Louisiana coast at the time of the deadly blast. Residents up and down the coast watched in horror as the spill continued for nearly three months, coating birds, fouling beaches and spoiling delicate fishing areas.
This summer, the global energy giant agreed to a record settlement of nearly $20 billion to states affected by the spill, hoping to resolve the legal drama that has cost the company billions. At the time, the company said the settlement would bring its full obligations to an estimated $53.8 billion. The company also agreed to plead guilty to manslaughter and pay $4 billion in criminal penalties.
Three years ago, then-Attorney General Eric Holder travelled to New Orleans to announce that deal as well as the charges against Rainey, Vidrine and Kaluza, whose lawyers swiftly portrayed them as scapegoats.
“There clearly was no evidence to support any of the charges brought against any of the individuals,” said Joan McPhee, one of Mix’s attorneys.
Prosecutors have said Vidrine and Kaluza botched a key safety test and disregarded abnormally high pressure readings indicating signs of trouble ahead of the blowout.
Vidrine is scheduled to be sentenced April 6, and U.S. District Judge Stanwood Duval Jr. did not indicate whether he will accept the sentence recommended by prosecutors, which includes 10 months of probation, 100 hours of community service and $50,000 in restitution for a project to fix damage from the oil spill.
Justice Department spokesman Peter Carr said in a statement that prosecutors dismissed the manslaughter charges “because circumstances surrounding the case have changed since it was originally charged, and after a careful review the department determined it can no longer meet the legal standard for instituting the involuntary manslaughter charges.”
The 2012 indictment charged Kaluza and Vidrine with 11 counts each of seaman’s manslaughter and 11 counts each of involuntary manslaughter. But a judge dismissed the seaman’s manslaughter charges, and the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that ruling in March.
To convict on involuntary manslaughter, prosecutors would have had to prove that Kaluza and Vidrine acted with a “wanton or reckless disregard for life.” David Uhlmann, a University of Michigan law professor and former chief of the Justice Department’s environmental crimes section, said it would have been “extremely difficult” for prosecutors to meet that burden of proof. Seaman’s manslaughter required mere negligence.
“The problem in the Gulf oil spill is not that the government tried to hold individuals responsible,” Uhlmann said. “The problem is that the responsibility lies with the senior corporate management that created a corporate culture that promoted risk taking and did not place sufficient emphasis on safety and environmental protection.”