WASHINGTON – It’s the scenario that’s been spooking employers and investors and slowing the US economy:
Congress and the White House fail to strike a budget deal by New Year’s Day. Their stalemate triggers sharp tax increases and spending cuts. Those measures shrink consumer spending, stifle job growth, topple stock prices and push the economy off a “fiscal cliff” and into recession.
The reality may be a lot less bleak.
Even if New Year’s passed with no deal, few businesses or consumers would likely panic as long as an agreement seemed likely soon. The tax increases and spending cuts could be retroactively repealed after Jan. 1.
And the impact of the tax increases would be felt only gradually. Most people would receive slightly less money in each paycheque.
“The simple conclusion that going off the cliff necessarily means a recession next year is wrong,” says Lewis Alexander, an economist at Nomura Securities. “It will ultimately depend on how long the policies are in place.”
Most economists expect a deal, if not by New Year’s then soon after. Businesses and consumers will likely remain calm as long as negotiators seem to be moving toward an agreement.
“The atmosphere is more important than whether the talks spill” into next year, said Paul Ashworth, an economist at Capital Economics.
Here’s why many are optimistic that a brief fall over the cliff wouldn’t derail the economic recovery:
• Though the fiscal cliff would cost the economy an estimated $671 billion for all of 2013, the tax hit for most people would be slight at first. The expiration of Social Security and income tax cuts would be spread throughout 2013. For taxpayers with incomes of $40,000 to $65,000, paycheques would shrink an average of about $1,500 next year but an average of just $130 in January, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center.
• About a third of the tax increases wouldn’t touch most Americans. Some would hit businesses. Others, such as higher taxes on investment income and estates, and the expiration of middle-income tax credits, wouldn’t come due until Americans filed their 2013 taxes in 2014.
• If a deal seemed imminent, some experts say the Internal Revenue Service could delay the increased tax withholding that’s due to kick in. Without a deal, the top income tax rate for single people with taxable income between about $36,000 and $88,000 would rise from 25% to 28%. A delay in the increased withholding would ease the initial tax hit.
• About $85 billion in spending cuts to defence and domestic programs would take weeks or longer to take effect. That means government agencies wouldn’t cut jobs right away.
Still, if budget talks dragged on, many businesses might put off investment or hiring. That’s why most economists say it would be crucial to reach a deal within roughly the first two months of 2013.
Already, uncertainty is causing some businesses to delay spending. Consider Apex Tool and Manufacturing, a 10-person shop in Evansville, Ind., that makes parts for the automotive glass, telecom equipment and plastics industries.
Sales have picked up. Company President Terry Babb says he’d like to spend about $150,000 to buy a computer-controlled milling machine. A couple of years ago, Apex earned too little for Babb to even worry about taxes.
Yet he’s reluctant to absorb new costs until he’s sure what tax changes are coming. A tax break for companies that invest in new equipment is set to expire. Companies can’t claim that break unless new equipment is on site before year’s end. Machinery can take weeks to arrive, meaning it’s too late for Babb to claim the credit this year.
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke said that the uncertainties about taxes are holding back the economy by causing businesses to postpone investment and hiring.
“Clearly, the fiscal cliff is having effects on the economy,” Bernanke said.